NN Logo

NatureNorth
Front Page

Summer Issue Page

Manitoba Monarchs

More Monarch Biology

In a way, it's unfortunate that monarch butterflies are so popular in Manitoba.

That's because they are such an anomaly as far as Manitoba butterflies go.

They are a migratory species, they don't live here year-round like most of our other 155 species of butterflies.

And they're the only representative of an otherwise tropical family of butterflies to be found in our province.

But they're big, beautiful and people love them. Just remember that monarchs are not a typical Manitoba butterfly.

 

 

 

 

You can help keep NatureNorth online and free to everyone with a secure donation through PayPal:

If your school or group makes use of this and other articles in NatureNorth, we hope you'll consider a donation.

Biology of the Monarch Butterfly

Description

(Click thumbnail images for larger photos.)

The monarch is one of Manitoba's largest butterflies, with a wingspan of up to 100 mm. The body of the butterfly is black with some white spots. The upper surfaces of the wings are orange with black veining. The wing margins are black with white spots. Males can be distinguished from the females by a black patch on their hind wings, called a stigmata. Underneath, the wings are a paler orange, almost beige, with the same black veining and borders. The caterpillar (larva) of monarchs is boldly patterned, too, with black, white and yellow banding.


Report Monarch Sightings directly at: Journey North


Name

The monarch butterfly is an insect (Class: Insecta), belonging to the subgroup of insects that includes the butterflies, moths and skippers (Order: Lepidoptera; from the Greek, "Lepis" = scale, "pteron" = wing). It is a member of the family, Nymphalidae and belongs to a further subgroup called the milkweed butterflies (Subfamily: Danainae). The monarch is the only species of this group, that contains 300 species world-wide, to occur in Canada.

Check out these projects:
Monarch Teaching Network Mission Monarch

The common name of this butterfly was assigned by early settlers to North America. There was, at the time, a King William (the 3rd, apparently), Prince of Orange, state holder of Holland, who would later be named King of England. The butterfly's colour lead to the name: monarch.

Its scientific name, Danaus plexippus, is derived as follows. (Or maybe not. I couldn't track down a definitive statement anywhere, so this is an educated guess.)

Genus: Danaus (Latin) from "Daunus", a fabled king of Apulia.

Danaus had 50 daughters who he ordered to kill their husbands on their wedding night. Each was given a dagger to carry out the deed. All but one complied. Perhaps this has to do with the stigmata mark on the hind wings of male monarchs?

Or perhaps it derives from "Danae". In Greek mythology, she is the woman who was imprisoned by her father because it was foretold that her son (Perseus) will kill him. Zeus comes down to the chamber as a golden shower and sleeps with her. They have a baby. Her father seals her and the baby in a chest and sets it a drift.

Species: plexippus (Greek) from "Plexippos", one of the numerous sons of Aegyptus.

Aegyptus's 50 sons married Danaus's 50 daughters. Plexippos is one of the sons killed by Danaus' daughters. Sounds like the stab-mark theory relating to the stigmata on male monarchs may be the key?

As I've mentioned before, scientific nomenclature stemming from earlier, more "romantic" times can be a little strange. At least the scientific name has some relation to the species' common name, in keeping with the theme of royalty. It just doesn't have much to do with the biology of the critter. I might have suggested "Asclepiovorus migratoria-rex". Read on and you'll be able to figure out why.

Monarch Relatives

Here's some of the monarch's relatives in the Subfamily Danainae. They are a common group of tropical butterflies and many even show seasonal migrations like our monarch, though none come close to migrating over the amazing distances the monarch does.

Distribution

Monarchs occur throughout North America south of the boreal forest zone, in Central America and northern South America. (It has recently been determined that the South American monarch and those found on Jamaica and Hispaniola are separate species, D. erippus and D. cleophile, respectively. Their distributions are not shown on this map.) Monarchs have been introduced to the Hawaiian Islands and to Australia, and are thought to be spreading around to other islands in the Pacific ocean on their own. There are 3 separate populations in continental North America: one east of the Rocky Mountains, another west of the Rockies, and a third, non-migratory population in Florida and Georgia. In Manitoba, they occur in the southwestern 1/3 of the province up to the edge of the boreal forest (see migration map below).

Monarch Distribution Map

Habitat

Just about anywhere you can find milkweed plants (Genus: Asclepias) and open meadows, you can find monarch butterflies. They frequent prairies, meadows and wetlands, but avoid thick forests. Food for the caterpillars, milkweed plants, and for the adults, flower nectar, are found mainly in grasslands and meadows in Manitoba, so that's where monarchs tend to be.


Icon
Their amazing migration seems to be what gets people most excited about monarchs, so we put the migration section here, even before the Life Cycle section (next page).

Migration

Monarchs are thought to be the only butterfly that truly migrates. Other species emigrate out from certain areas as their food supply emerges with the changing seasons, but in no other species do adults actively return to a certain site at the end of the growing season.

Monarchs must travel to and from Manitoba each year, though it's unlikely that any one butterfly that leaves this province will ever return. Most of those making the return trip will be their progeny. Adult monarchs hatched out here in mid to late summer will fly south all the way to the wintering grounds in central Mexico, over 3000 km away! They reach the wintering grounds by mid-October, averaging over 50 km per day on their southward migration. In spring, around mid-March, our Manitoba monarchs will begin the journey northward, but most only make it as far as the southern US, where they will start a new generation. (Research published in 2011 shows that up to 10% of monarchs returning to Canada have made the entire round trip. The numbers that might make it back to Manitoba are unknown.) The first monarchs to make it back to Manitoba in late May or early June are likely the children of the ones that left here the previous fall. Some of the grandchildren of our original Manitoba monarchs may make it to Manitoba, too, later in the summer. (The monarchs living west of the Rocky Mountains migrate to sites in southern California to overwinter.)


IconWe had to update our migration map in 2012 as new research has shown that up to 10% of monarchs may actually be making the round trip from Canada to Mexico and back to Canada! This is a truly staggering feat for a delicate insect. All the more reason to be impressed by the marvelous monarch butterfly.

Check out this article: Migratory Connectivity of the Monarch Butterfly.


Why do monarchs migrate? In spring and summer their northward journey gives them access to more and more emerging milkweed plants for their caterpillars and gets the adults into areas where there is less competition for flower nectar. But why south to Mexico in the fall? Are they seeking warmer climes with abundant food? Actually, they are seeking the opposite. What monarchs need to successfully overwinter are cool, moist, protected surroundings. They find these conditions in mountainous regions of Click Herecentral Mexico. Monarchs congregate by the millions, in a few isolated locations in forests within the mountain valleys. These overwintering sites were not even discovered until 1975! And that was only after a lengthy investigation involving a tagging program that saw thousands of monarchs fitted with tiny wing tags!

In their Mexican retreat, the monarchs have fairly stable weather conditions, with cool, but not freezing temperatures (monarchs are not freeze-tolerant), high humidity and protection from damaging winds. They converge on very small patches of forest and cluster together, often covering the individual trees. They rest and conserve their energy, drawing slowly on their stores of body fat, produced from the nectar of flowers they visited on their journey south. And there they remain, rousing occasionally to flutter about and perhaps sip some water from local ponds, then return to their hibernation, until about mid-March. With the return of spring, they rouse and begin their journey northward.

How do monarchs migrate? It's thought that monarchs use the position of the sun, combined with an innate circadian rhythm, and the earth's magnetic field to determine north and south while on their journey. Monarchs are strong fliers, but also make use of favourable winds, and may even make use of rising columns of air, thermals, to gain altitude, then glide for long distances without expending energy in flapping. In North America, the funnelling effect of the shape of the southern U.S. and central Mexico likely helps monarchs end up in the same places each year.

There is still much to be learned about monarch migration. For example, how do changing environmental conditions in late summer turn off reproduction in the emerging adults and "flip their switches" from "fly north" to "fly south"? The real secrets of why and how monarchs migrate to the exact spots that they do, still remains trapped within their genes.


IconWatch for monarchs to show up in southern Manitoba after the first strong, warm south winds of early summer. These "hair-drier" winds that gust up from the central United States help blow the monarchs up here. Monarchs usually show up around Winnipeg in the first or second week of June.

Food

Food for adult monarch butterflies consists mainly of flower nectar. They fuel their great travels and reproductive efforts by sipping this sugary solution from obliging plants. The plants are, of course, taking advantage of the monarchs and other insects to do the job of pollination. Most of their favourites fall within the Asteraceae family of plants, including such things as fleabanes (Erigeron spp.), asters (Aster spp.), sunflowers (Helianthus spp.) and blazingstars (Liatris spp.), but they are not really that selective when it comes to flower nectar. Any flower that has available nectar could be visited by a monarch. (For more information on nectar sources for butterflies in general, check out our Butterfly Gardening article.)

The most important food for monarchs is that which the caterpillars eat, milkweed (see If You Grow It, They Will Come, next page). Monarch caterpillars, like the caterpillars of most butterflies and moths, have evolved fairly restricted diets. Monarch caterpillars eat the flowers and leaves, and sometimes the seed pods, of milkweed plants. They are one of the few caterpillars that does eat members of the milkweed family. These plants contain a thick, foul-tasting milky liquid, hence the name, that flows into areas of the plant that have been damaged: eaten or broken. This liquid is primarily intended as a deterrent to insects eating the plant. Monarchs can get partly around this defence, by chewing holes in the base of the main veins of leaves before they eat them, thus preventing excess "milk" from pouring into the leaf. The plants have other chemical defences, though, one of which the monarchs even turn to their own use.

Play the video to watch milkweed munching!

Content on this page requires a newer version of Adobe Flash Player.

Get Adobe Flash player

Toxic Defence and Mimicry

Milkweed tissues contain compounds, called cardenolides, that are quite toxic. Intended by the plant as a chemical deterrent to being eaten, monarch caterpillars are immune to these and actually accumulate the toxins in their own tissues, rendering them toxic, too. The bold patterning of monarch caterpillars advertises this fact. Should a bird attempt to eat a monarch caterpillar, it will become ill, usually vomiting out the caterpillar, and will refrain from eating any more. Bold warning coloration, reinforced by the occasional bad meal, leaves monarch caterpillars safe from most avian predators. If attacked, a monarch caterpillar will roll up in a ball and fall off the milkweed plant to the ground below, where it will remain curled up until the danger has passed. In this position its bright warning colours are even more pronounced.

No defence is perfect, however, and just as the monarch caterpillars have evolved resistance to the milkweed's toxins, so too have other insects developed resistance to the caterpillar's defence. Several kinds of parasitic flies and wasps, plus a variety of micro-organisms take their toll on monarch caterpillars.

Monarch butterflies retain the toxic defence that originated in their caterpillar stage. Their bold black and orange coloration advertises this, and potential predators learn to avoid this species. This defence is so good that it even offers protection to another unrelated species of butterfly, the viceroy (Limenitis archippus). Viceroy butterflies, which are also quite common in Manitoba, are not toxic or bad tasting, but they have evolved to look very similar to monarchs, thus gaining some protection from predators that have learned not to eat monarchs. This sneaky trick is an example of "Batesian mimicry", a fairly common technique employed in the insect world.


IconMonarch Images of butterflies, live or dead?

We often see images of butterflies in art or advertising. Unfortunately, the pose in which butterflies are often set is that of a dead butterfly! Click the picture on the right to see what we mean.


Carry on for Even more about Monarchs!


Icon

Attention all butterfly lovers!

Check out this new citizen science project: eButterfly. Now you can enter your sightings of butterflies and help build a great new database of Canadian butterflies!


Return to Manitoba Monarchs | Summer Issue | NatureNorth Front Page